How to compare quotes so the cheapest one is not the dearest
Getting three quotes is standard advice. NSW's licensing guidance says to "get more than one written quote", and WA Consumer Protection says at least three. What nobody mentions is that three quotes for three different jobs tell you nothing.
Write the brief first
Before you ring anyone, write down:
- what you want done, room by room or item by item,
- what it is for (this switches on the fit-for-purpose guarantee),
- materials or brands you want, or "tradie to recommend",
- access issues: stairs, parking, a dog, working hours,
- when you need it finished.
Send the same brief to everyone. Now the quotes can be compared.
Quote or estimate?
Ask which one you are getting, and get the answer in writing.
| Quote | Estimate | |
|---|---|---|
| Meaning | A fixed price for a described job | A best guess |
| Can the price rise? | Only if the job changes and you agree | Yes |
| When it suits | You can define the work | Fault-finding, hidden damage, hourly work |
If it has to be an estimate, ask for a range and a ceiling: "A$900 to A$1,300, and you will call me before going past A$1,300."
What a fair quote contains
- The business name, ABN and licence number where a licence applies.
- A description of the work detailed enough that a stranger could tell what is included.
- Materials by brand, model, grade or colour.
- What is excluded. A good quote says so.
- The total price including GST. The ACCC's rule is that a displayed price must be the total, including taxes and all unavoidable fees.
- Deposit and payment stages.
- Start date, duration, and how long the quote is valid.
- Warranty on workmanship.
NSW Fair Trading's line about removalists applies to every trade: the quote should be itemised, and the business should be able to account for every charge.
Comparing
Put the quotes side by side in a table, one row per item. Where one quote is silent, ring and ask. You will usually find the cheap quote is missing something: rubbish removal, a second coat, the electrical connection, making good.
Then compare the things that are not price:
- Who is doing the work, and are they licensed for it?
- When can they start, and how long will it take?
- How did they behave during quoting? A tradie who turns up on time, measures properly and answers questions is showing you how the job will run.
The quote that is far lower
A quote 30% under the others has an explanation. Sometimes it is a hungry new business. More often it is a thinner specification, no licence, no insurance, or a plan to recover the difference in variations. Ask the business, directly and without accusation, why it is lower. The answer is informative either way.
Free quotes and paid quotes
A business can charge for a quote, but under the pricing rules it has to be upfront about the fee before you agree to the visit. Paid quotes are common where diagnosis is the work, as with a mechanic or an appliance repairer. Ask whether the fee comes off the bill if you go ahead.
Quick questions
Is a verbal quote binding?
A verbal agreement can be a contract, but you will struggle to prove its terms. Ask for the quote by text or email, even if it is two lines.
The final bill was higher than the quote and nothing changed. Do I have to pay the difference?
If it was a fixed quote and you did not agree to extras, you can dispute the excess. Pay the quoted amount, say why in writing, and ask for an itemised bill.
Sources
Opened and read in November 2026. Follow the links for the current wording.
- Price displays ACCC
- False or misleading claims ACCC
- Choosing a removalist NSW Fair Trading
- Checking your contractor or tradesperson is qualified NSW Government
- Choose your removalist wisely as rogue operators attract complaints WA Consumer Protection
- Receipts, bills, proof of purchase ACCC
General information for Australian consumers, not legal advice. Spotted an error? Tell us.