Reading online reviews like a sceptic
Reviews are the main way people now choose a tradie, which makes them the main thing a dishonest tradie will manipulate. You do not need to ignore reviews. You need to read them the way a regulator would.
What the law says
The ACCC's guidance on reviews is direct: "It's against the law for a business to create fake or misleading reviews or to arrange for others to do so."
A review can mislead when:
- it is written by the business, a family member, an employee or someone paid, without saying so,
- the reviewer never used the service,
- someone else edited it after it was written.
Suppressing the bad ones counts too. The ACCC says removing or editing genuine negative reviews may mislead consumers, and a business needs an adequate basis to believe a review is fake before it takes it down.
The enforcement record
These are cases from the ACCC's page, not hypotheticals:
| Business | What happened | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| HealthEngine | Suppressed and edited patient reviews | Ordered to pay A$2.9 million |
| Service Seeking | Published reviews that businesses had drafted themselves | Ordered to pay A$600,000 |
| Citymove | Copied and altered testimonials | Paid a A$6,600 infringement notice penalty |
Two of the three involve platforms, which is a reminder that the site hosting the reviews is not a neutral referee.
The ACCC's warning signs
- "A spike in highly positive or negative reviews over a short period of time."
- Lots of reviews from similar reviewer names, or the same email or IP address (visible to platforms, not to you, but the pattern often shows in the names).
- Generic wording with no specific details.
The ACCC adds that platforms requiring proof of purchase may be more reliable.
How to read a profile
Sort by newest, not "most relevant". You want to know how the business has behaved in the past six months.
Read the middle. Three-star and four-star reviews tend to be written by real customers describing real trade-offs: good work, slow to return calls.
Look for detail. "Replaced our hot water unit, turned up at 7, found a corroded valve and showed me before replacing it" is hard to fake at volume. "Great service highly recommend A+++" is not.
Read the replies to bad reviews. A calm, specific reply that offers to fix the problem is a good sign. A reply that attacks the customer, or the same pasted paragraph under every complaint, tells you how your own complaint will go.
Check the count behind the stars. The ACCC says platforms should show context such as the total number of reviews behind a rating. A 5.0 from six reviews means much less than a 4.6 from three hundred.
Leave the business's own website out of it. Writing about solar retailers, the ACCC notes that some businesses only publish positive reviews on their own sites or post fake reviews elsewhere. Testimonials chosen by the business are marketing.
Incentives
Offering a discount for a review is risky but not banned. The ACCC's conditions are that the incentive is offered whether the review is positive or negative, and that it is "clearly disclosed so consumers know the review was incentivised". "Leave us five stars for A$50 off" fails on both counts.
What reviews cannot tell you
Whether the licence is current, whether the ABN matches, whether the insurance exists. Those take ten minutes on the regulator's register and ABN Lookup, and they are facts.
Quick questions
Can a business sue me over an honest bad review?
An honest account of your own experience, stuck to facts you can prove, is the safest kind. Avoid guesses about motives and keep your evidence. If you receive a legal letter, get advice before replying.
How do I report fake reviews?
Report them to the platform, and to the ACCC through its report form. The ACCC does not resolve individual disputes but uses reports to decide what to investigate.
Sources
Opened and read in November 2026. Follow the links for the current wording.
General information for Australian consumers, not legal advice. Spotted an error? Tell us.