Paying safely: which payment methods you can get back
How you pay matters most when things go wrong. The day a tradie stops answering the phone, the question is whether your payment can be pulled back or whether it is simply gone.
The methods, ranked by recoverability
| Method | Can it be reversed? | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Credit card | Yes, by chargeback through your bank | Time limits apply |
| Debit card | Yes, chargebacks cover debit and credit cards | Same |
| PayPal | Has its own dispute process | Consumer Affairs Victoria gives 180 days from payment |
| Bank transfer, PayID | Generally no | Treated like a money transfer |
| BPAY, direct debit, cheque | Generally no chargeback | |
| Cash | No | And no record unless you get a receipt |
The chargeback rows come from Consumer Affairs Victoria, which says a chargeback "may not be available" if you paid by cash, money transfer, cheque, direct debit or BPAY.
The surcharge excuse is gone
Tradies used to steer people to bank transfer by adding a fee for card. The ACCC says that from 1 October 2026 businesses can no longer surcharge payments by Visa, Mastercard, American Express or eftpos cards. They can still offer a discount for another method, such as cash or PayID, if the full price is clearly displayed.
So you may be offered "A$50 off for transfer". Decide what the protection is worth to you. On a A$300 job from a plumber you have used for years, take the discount. On a A$4,000 deposit to a business you found last week, pay by card.
Staging payments
The safest payment is one made after the work is done. Where that is not possible:
- Keep the deposit small. For home building work your state probably caps it.
- Tie each payment to a finished stage you can see, not to a date.
- Hold a meaningful final payment until the job is complete and you have checked it.
- Never pay the whole price before work starts.
If you do pay by transfer
- Check the account name matches the business name on the quote and the entity on ABN Lookup. A personal account in a different name is a reason to stop and ask.
- Confirm bank details by phoning a number you already had, not one in the email containing the invoice. That guards against a fake invoice with altered account numbers.
- Put the invoice number in the reference field.
- Screenshot the confirmation.
Consumer Affairs Victoria's guidance for people who paid by instant cash transfer and got nothing is brief: contact the police, who may be able to help. That tells you how few options there are.
If you pay cash
Get a receipt at the moment you hand it over. A business must give one for anything over A$75, showing its name, ABN or ACN, what was supplied, the date and the price. If there is no receipt book, write the details on the quote and have the tradie sign it, or send a text straight away: "Paid A$600 cash today for the fence repair, thanks." Their reply is your record.
Keep the trail
Whatever the method: quote, invoice, receipt, bank or card statement. If you ever need a chargeback, a fair trading complaint or a tribunal claim, those four documents are most of your case.
Quick questions
Is buy now, pay later protected like a card?
The ACCC notes these services are regulated separately and that fees may apply. Check the provider's own dispute process before relying on it for a large payment.
The tradie only takes cash or transfer. Should I walk away?
Not necessarily. Plenty of honest sole traders have no card terminal. Reduce the risk another way: small deposit, payment on completion, a proper invoice and an ABN that checks out.
Sources
Opened and read in November 2026. Follow the links for the current wording.
- Chargeback Consumer Affairs Victoria
- Card surcharges ACCC
- Payment methods ACCC
- Receipts, bills, proof of purchase ACCC
- Resolve your problem or complaint Consumer Affairs Victoria
General information for Australian consumers, not legal advice. Spotted an error? Tell us.