Variations and extras: how a A$9,000 job becomes A$14,000
Hardly any job finishes at exactly the quoted price, and that is not always the tradie's doing. Walls hide rot. You change your mind about the tiles. The trouble starts when changes are agreed with a nod in a doorway and priced after the fact.
Three ways the price moves
Real variations. You ask for something different, or something unexpected turns up. Legitimate, as long as it is priced and agreed first.
Allowances. The quote included a "provisional sum" or "prime cost item": a placeholder figure for something not yet chosen or not yet known. If the placeholder was low, the bill rises without anyone changing anything.
Unauthorised extras. Work nobody asked for, discovered on the invoice.
The rule to set on day one
Put this in writing before work starts. A text will do:
- "Before any work outside the quote, please send me the price in writing and wait for my OK."
For building work some states already require something like it. Consumer Affairs Victoria says variations must be agreed in writing and recorded in the contract, including the new price and completion date, before the work is done. In NSW, contracts over A$20,000 must include clauses requiring variations to be in writing and signed by both parties.
Borrow that standard for a A$600 job as readily as a A$60,000 one.
What a written variation needs
Four lines:
- What is changing.
- The price, including GST, as an addition to or deduction from the contract.
- The effect on the finish date.
- Your approval, with the date.
A photo of the problem attached is a bonus. Reply "approved" and file it.
Taming allowances
Before signing, find every provisional sum and prime cost item in the quote and ask:
- What is this figure based on?
- What is the realistic range?
- What mark-up applies if the actual cost is higher?
NSW's guide to choosing a builder warns about provisional cost items for this reason. For anything you can choose in advance, such as tiles, taps and appliances, choose it and have the real price written in.
In Victoria, you can ask for a copy of any invoice or receipt for prime cost or provisional sum items, and the builder must provide it.
Cost-plus contracts are the extreme case: you pay actual costs plus a margin, with no fixed total. The QBCC says reports show final costs on these can exceed expectations by 50 to 100 per cent. Avoid them unless there is truly no way to define the work.
Hidden damage
Some discoveries really are unforeseeable. Agree in advance how they will be handled: work stops on that area, the tradie shows you and photographs it, gives a written price, and you decide. An agreed hourly rate for "unforeseen work" in the original quote stops the negotiation happening while your kitchen is in pieces.
Consumer Affairs Victoria adds a useful point: you may not have to pay for changes the builder should reasonably have foreseen when the contract was signed.
Extras you never approved
If an invoice includes work you did not ask for:
- Ask for an itemised bill. You have 30 days to request one and the business has 7 days to supply it.
- Pay the amount for the agreed work.
- Dispute the rest in writing, briefly: "Items 4 and 5 were not requested or approved. I have paid A$X for the quoted work."
A contract term letting the business vary the price at will, without your agreement, is the kind of one-sided term the unfair contract terms law is aimed at.
When you are the one changing things
Be fair about it. If you add a power point, move a wall or upgrade the benchtop, that is a variation and the tradie is entitled to charge for it. Ask for the price first and you will rarely argue about it later.
Quick questions
The tradie did extra work that really was needed. Do I have to pay?
If it was necessary and you would have agreed, paying a fair price is reasonable. You can still object to the amount, and to not being asked. An itemised bill helps you judge the figure.
Can a variation be agreed verbally?
It can form an agreement, but proof is the problem. Confirm it by text straight away with the price.
Sources
Opened and read in November 2026. Follow the links for the current wording.
- Deposits and payments for building work Consumer Affairs Victoria
- Contracts for residential building work NSW Government
- Step by step guide to choosing the right tradesperson or builder NSW Government
- Understanding deposits and progress payments Queensland Building and Construction Commission
- Receipts, bills, proof of purchase ACCC
- Unfair contract terms (business guidance) ACCC
General information for Australian consumers, not legal advice. Spotted an error? Tell us.