Major or minor? The question that decides your remedy
The Australian Consumer Law gives you remedies against a service business in section 267. Which remedy you get hangs on one distinction, set out in section 268: is the failure major or not?
The test for a major problem
According to the ACCC, a service has a major problem when it:
- creates an unsafe situation,
- has one serious problem or several smaller problems that would have stopped someone buying the service if they had known, or
- cannot be used for its normal purpose, or for a purpose or result you told the business about, and cannot easily be fixed within a reasonable time.
Note the middle one. A pile of small faults can add up to a major failure. Ten defects in a bathroom renovation, none dramatic alone, may together be something no sane person would have paid for.
Side by side
| Minor problem | Major problem | |
|---|---|---|
| Who chooses the fix | The business | You |
| First step | Business repairs it free, within a reasonable time | You can cancel straight away |
| Money | No refund if they fix it properly | Refund, less a reasonable amount for good work already done, or a reduced price if you keep the contract |
| If they stall or refuse | Get it fixed elsewhere and claim the reasonable cost, or cancel | Go to fair trading or the tribunal |
| Compensation for other damage | Yes, if foreseeable | Yes, if foreseeable |
Worked examples
Minor. An electrician installs six downlights and one flickers. The fix is a ten minute return visit. You cannot demand all your money back, but you can insist on the visit at no charge.
Major, unsafe. A gas heater is serviced and afterwards smells of gas. That is unsafe. You do not have to let the same business back in.
Major, not fit and not easily fixed. A removalist was booked to move a piano up one flight of stairs, and turns up without the equipment or the people to do it. The job cannot be done that day and you have settlement at noon.
Minor that grows up. A fence is out of line. The fencer promises to come back, then goes quiet for a month. The ACCC says that if a business cannot or will not fix a minor problem within a reasonable time, you can have the work done elsewhere and be repaid the reasonable cost, or cancel.
How to say it
When you contact the business, name the category. For a major problem, the ACCC's advice on contacting a business is to say you are rejecting the service and state the remedy you want. For a minor one, ask for the repair and give a date. Our letter templates have wording for both.
Quick questions
Who decides if it is major?
You make the call first, and the business may disagree. If you cannot settle it, a tribunal decides. That is why evidence matters: photos, an independent opinion and the original quote.
The business offered a credit note. Do I have to take it?
Not for a major problem. You are entitled to a refund of what you paid for the failed part of the service, in the form you paid.
Sources
Opened and read in November 2026. Follow the links for the current wording.
- Competition and Consumer Act 2010, Schedule 2 (the Australian Consumer Law) Federal Register of Legislation
- Repair, replace, refund, cancel ACCC
- Contacting a business to fix a problem ACCC
- Choosing a removalist NSW Fair Trading
General information for Australian consumers, not legal advice. Spotted an error? Tell us.