the canny buyer

Your rights

When the job breaks something else: compensation for damage and loss

A plumber replaces a flexi hose under the sink and does not tighten it. You come home to a swollen kitchen cabinet and a cupped timber floor. The hose costs A$20. The floor does not.

Section 267 of the Australian Consumer Law lets a consumer recover damages for loss or damage caused by a failure to meet a guarantee, if it was reasonably foreseeable that you would suffer that loss as a result. This sits on top of the repair or refund.

What the regulator says

The ACCC's compensation page sets the aim: "Compensation should put the consumer back in the financial position they were in before the problem happened."

It also makes two points worth quoting to a stubborn business:

  • "Businesses must not claim that a consumer has no right to this compensation."
  • It is misleading, and against the law, for a business to say it is not responsible for foreseeable losses.

Foreseeable or not

The test is whether a reasonable person in the business's position could have seen this kind of loss coming.

The ACCC gives a pair of examples. A washing machine with a fault leaks and ruins carpet: foreseeable, so the business pays for the carpet. A new car leaks oil on the driveway, and the owner's dog runs through the oil and into the house: the dealer pays to clean the driveway but not the lounge room carpet, because nobody could have predicted the dog.

For services the same logic applies.

What happenedLikely foreseeable?
Loose plumbing fitting floods a floorYes
Removalist drops a TVYes
Roofer leaves tiles off before forecast rain, ceiling collapsesYes
Late delivery of a kitchen means you eat takeaway for a monthSome of it, with receipts
You missed a job interview because the locksmith was lateHard to claim

How much

Claim what it costs to put things right, not a windfall. The ACCC's dry cleaner example is the one to remember: if a cleaner ruins curtains that were already worn, it would be reasonable for the cleaner to pay part, not all, of the cost of new ones. Age and condition count.

The ACCC adds that most costs are financial but others, such as lost time or productivity, can be included. Expect to justify those carefully.

Building the claim

  1. Stop the damage getting worse. Turn off the water, cover the hole, move the furniture. You are expected to limit your loss.
  2. Photograph everything before it is cleaned up.
  3. Tell the business in writing the same day, and invite them to inspect.
  4. Get one or two written repair quotes.
  5. Send a claim that lists each item, its cost and the evidence. Give a date to respond.

Your own home and contents insurer may also pay, then chase the business itself. That can be faster, but you may wear an excess and a claim on your record. For a small loss, a direct claim on the business is often simpler.

Quick questions

The contract says the business is "not liable for any consequential loss". Is that the end of it?

No. The consumer guarantees cannot be excluded by contract, and the ACCC says it is misleading for a business to claim it is not responsible for foreseeable losses caused by its failure.

Can I claim for stress and inconvenience?

Compensation under the guarantees is mainly about financial loss. Tribunals are cautious about distress on its own. Put your energy into the losses you can prove with documents.

Sources

Opened and read in November 2026. Follow the links for the current wording.

General information for Australian consumers, not legal advice. Spotted an error? Tell us.

Keep reading

All of your rights