the canny buyer

Your rights

Due care and skill: the standard every tradie has to meet

Section 60 of the Australian Consumer Law is a single idea: if a business supplies you a service, it guarantees the service "will be rendered with due care and skill". Lawyers have argued for decades about those five words. For a homeowner the working version is simpler.

Two halves to the test

The ACCC describes it this way: the work must be at least as good as a competent provider with average skills would deliver, and the provider must take reasonable steps to avoid causing loss or damage.

So there are two questions.

  1. Skill. Was the result up to the ordinary standard of the trade? Paint that peels in a month because nobody primed the timber fails. A slightly visible brush mark near the cornice probably does not.
  2. Care. Did they look after your property while doing it? A plumber who fixes the leak beautifully and floods the hallway doing it has still broken the guarantee.

What it looks like when it fails

  • A tiler lays a shower floor that falls away from the drain, so water pools in the corner.
  • A removalist stacks a marble table under a fridge and it arrives in two pieces.
  • A mechanic changes the oil and leaves the sump plug finger tight.
  • A cleaner uses an acid cleaner on natural stone and etches the benchtop.

None of these needs a contract clause to be a problem. The standard comes from the trade itself: manufacturer instructions, Australian Standards, the building code, and what other competent operators would say if you showed them photos.

How to prove it

This is where most complaints wobble. "It looks bad" is an opinion. Evidence is better.

  • Dated photos and video, wide shots and close-ups.
  • The quote, texts and emails showing what was agreed.
  • A short written opinion from a second tradie in the same trade. Ask them to say what is wrong, why it does not meet the usual standard, and what it would cost to fix. One page is plenty.
  • For building work, your state's building regulator often publishes a guide to standards and tolerances. NSW's dispute guidance points to its own one as a way to judge what is acceptable.

What you can ask for

A minor shortfall has to be fixed free within a reasonable time. A major one opens the door to cancelling and a refund. If careless work damaged something else, such as your floor, your car or your garden, you can also claim compensation for the damage, as long as the loss was reasonably foreseeable.

Quick questions

The tradie says the damage was "an accident". Does that matter?

Not much. The guarantee covers taking reasonable steps to avoid loss or damage. If a competent operator would have covered the floor, moved the vase or isolated the water first, then not doing so is the failure.

Does a cheap price lower the standard?

Price can affect what finish or materials you were promised. It does not license careless work. A budget job still has to be competent.

Sources

Opened and read in November 2026. Follow the links for the current wording.

General information for Australian consumers, not legal advice. Spotted an error? Tell us.

Keep reading

All of your rights