the canny buyer

Your rights

Getting your money back when a service goes wrong

Goods are easy: you hand the toaster back and get your money. A service cannot be handed back. The lawn is already mown badly, the wall already painted the wrong colour. So the law takes a different route.

The three money outcomes

Under sections 267 and 269 of the Australian Consumer Law, and as the ACCC explains, the options are:

  1. Fix it. For a minor problem, the business repairs the work at no charge. No refund is owed if the repair is done properly and promptly.
  2. Cancel and refund. For a major problem, or a minor one the business will not fix in a reasonable time, you can end the contract. You get a refund, but "this may not be a full refund", in the ACCC's words, because you pay a reasonable amount for work already done.
  3. Keep the contract, pay less. For a major problem you can instead keep what has been done and ask for a price reduction that reflects the drop in value.

The mandatory warranty wording for services says the same thing in one sentence: for a major failure you are entitled "to cancel your service contract with us" and "to a refund for the unused portion, or to compensation for its reduced value".

Doing the sums

Say you paid A$4,000 to have a courtyard paved. Two thirds is fine. One third has sunk because the base was not compacted, and the paver will not return.

A fair claim looks like this:

  • Cost for another paver to lift and relay the failed section: get a written quote, say A$1,900.
  • Any extra loss caused by the failure, such as a damaged drain.
  • Less nothing for the good section, because you are keeping it and have already paid for it.

You are not asking for A$4,000. You are asking for the reasonable cost of getting what you paid for. Claims built this way are hard to argue with.

Prepaid and unused

If you paid up front and the business did little or nothing, the position is cleaner. The ACCC says that with prepayments "the amount depends on whether some or all services had problems, or were not provided at all". Services never provided should be refunded in full.

A business that goes quiet after taking a deposit may also have a section 36 problem: it is unlawful to accept payment without intending to supply, or knowing it cannot supply in time. See the ACCC's page on not receiving what you paid for.

If they simply refuse

  • Paid by credit or debit card? Ask your bank about a chargeback. Consumer Affairs Victoria says time limits vary from 45 to 120 days from the transaction, so do not wait. Our chargeback piece walks through it.
  • Send a written demand with a deadline. A template is on the letters page.
  • Take it to your state's fair trading agency, then the tribunal. The disputes section has the limits and fees.

Quick questions

Can the business keep my deposit if I cancel because of their bad work?

If you are cancelling because a consumer guarantee was not met, the starting point is that you get back what you paid, less a reasonable amount for sound work already done. A "non-refundable deposit" term does not override that.

How long do I have to claim?

The consumer law does not give one neat deadline for complaining to a business, but tribunals have limits. NCAT, for example, requires a consumer claim within 3 years of the cause of action. Act early; evidence goes stale.

Sources

Opened and read in November 2026. Follow the links for the current wording.

General information for Australian consumers, not legal advice. Spotted an error? Tell us.

Keep reading

All of your rights